If you have sensitive eyes it can be quite a challenge, especially when you’re trying to find the right makeup for your skin.
Most eyeshadows tend to irritate your eyes causing them to become itchy, red, and watery because of the harmful ingredients in the formulas.
Applying makeup shouldn’t be a nightmare and with the best eyeshadow for sensitive eyes, it doesn’t have to be.
However, you’ll need to pay closer attention to the components in the eye makeup you use.
Your eyes are one of the most delicate parts of your body and the most likely to react sensitively to products than other parts of your body.
Got for cosmetics that are free of paraben, sulfates, and other ingredients that could irritate.
Our Pick of Top 3 Natural Eyeshadows
Here are the 7 Best Eyeshadows for sensitive eyes you can choose from.
This is an all-natural and long-lasting eyeshadow that is safe for people with sensitive eyes and skin and those who wear contact lenses since it’s free of talc, parabens, and synthetic perfumes.
It’s formulated with safe minerals, vitamin E, and natural extracts from honey and bamboo.
This eyeshadow is available in 4 different palettes 2 warm-toned and 2 cool-toned that include countryside lavender, shimmering nudes, dusky woods, and blooming desert that are simple and practical to use every day to give your eyes that natural subtle look.
These colors are very easy to blend and don’t smudge, crease, or fade with time.
Natural Show Highlights:
EYE SHADOW PALETTE: Our eye shadow compact contains three beautiful nude shades of easy-to-blend, long-lasting rich mineral color that resists creasing, fading, and smudging.
INGREDIENTS FOR NOURISHMENT: This makeup is specially formulated for your delicate eye area and is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, as it is made with 100 percent natural ingredients such as bamboo, honey, and vitamin products.
SHADOW OF THE SHIMMER EYE: Each eye shadow is lightly pigmented and has a subtle shimmer that makes it ideal for everyday use – Blooming Dessert is characterized by tawny copper, brown, and light nude tones.
EYE SHADOW TRIO: Available in four distinct eye palette trios inspired by nature, choose the color that best complements you. Shimmering Nudes, Blooming Desert, Lavender in the Countryside, and Dusky Woods
MAKEUP WITH NATURAL INGREDIENTS: Burt’s Bees eye shadow has been ophthalmologist tested and is free of parabens, phthalates, SLS, petrolatum, talc, synthetic fragrances, and silicones. Animals were never tested.
Ingredients Burt’s Bee Natural Shadows:
Ingredients: mica, squalane, silica, silica, lauroyl lysine, zinc stearate, glyceryl caprylate, bambusa arundinacea stem extract (bamboo), mel (honey), jojoba esters, simmondsia chinensis (jojoba) seed oil, tocopherol.
Maltodextrin, glycine soja (soybean) oil, glyceryl undecylenate, stearoyl glutamic acid, linoleic acid, linolenic acid.
May contain: titanium oxide, iron oxides and tin oxides.
Is Burts Bees makeup natural?
Before we begin, a word about the Burt’s Bees Beauty makeup line.
All of the products on this list are 99.9% or more natural.
They are free of parabens, phthalates, SLS, petrolatum, and synthetic fragrances.
They have been dermatologist-tested and have never been tested on animals.
Are Burt’s Bees natural and organic?
- Made with natural ingredients
- Very comfortable to wear all-day
- Give you a nice subtle look
- Great consistency
- You need to use a primer
- The packaging isn’t great
This is the perfect eyeshadow palette you can wear every day that is infused with minerals and coconut water to keep your eyes nourished and hydrated all day.
The 10 different colors on the palette have versatile shades you can use to create different looks from subtle to bold looks and are highly pigmented with a creamy, velvety finish.
The shadows won’t irritate your eyes and are perfect for people with sensitive eyes and skin.
- Apply smoothly and evenly
- Attractive colors that blend well
- Great for everyday wear
- Made with natural ingredients
- Doesn’t come with brushes
This is a versatile eyeshadow palette that comes with highly pigmented shades you can wear both day and night.
Each of the 10 colors blends easily and has different finishes with a velvety feel.
Some will give you a matte finish that you can use as a liner when wet while others have a more shimmery or shiny finish that gives you a high shine finish when wet.
If you sweat or rub your eyes accidentally, the staying powder will ensure the eyeshadow doesn’t come off.
- Stays on even when you sweat
- Highly pigmented colors
- Versatile finishes for all skin tones
- It’s quite messy when applying
Lorac Pro palette eyeshadow kit
This eyeshadow is designed to care for your skin and is formulated with gentle and soothing ingredients.
The shadows are formulated with soothing botanicals and natural extracts ingredients like parsley, cucumber, and lemon.
It has 16 shadows in its palette with a combination of both mattes and shimmer that you can use wet or dry to create the perfect look your desire.
This eyeshadow has great pigments that are very easy to blend with very little chance of fallouts.
Although the colors are powder-based, they give you a creamy feel when applying to your eyelids.
However, it’s best to use a primer before applying your eyeshadow o ensure it stays on for longer without flaking or smudging.
- Long-lasting quality shadows
- Smooth consistency
- Easy to blend
- Powder-based but has a creamy texture
- Need to use a primer
- Made with a type of paraben
Revlon Illuminance Crème Shadow, Not Just Nudes
This shadow contains a variety of colors and finishes including a cream palette with 4 coordinated shades that you can easily blend to create the perfect color combinations that will give you a new look every time.
The 6 luminous palettes will glide on smoothly and are crease-resistant, but you’ll need to use a primer or powder if you have oily eyelids so they don’t crease on your lids and it lasts longer.
- Glides on smoothly
- Blends well
- Different color palettes give you different looks
- Easy to apply
- Contains talc
- Need to use a primer
Physicians formula extreme shimmer shadow
This eyeshadow is hypoallergenic which makes it a great choice for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
This nude eye palette is great for everyday wear while the smoky palette will give you a great evening look. However, the eyeshadow will give you a more sparkly than matte finish because it has glitter particles, so it’s not the best option if you’re looking for a subtle look.
This highly pigmented liquid powder blends easily and is creaseless so it will stay on for more than 24 hours.
- Beautiful colors
- No makeup crease lines on your eyelids
- All-day wear
- Blends well
- The glitters get in your eyes
- Very powdery
Almay intense i-color
This eyeshadow is designed to enhance the color of your eyes and it comes in 4 different color palettes of brown, hazel, green, and blue.
The colors have a lighter pigmentation so you’ll need to apply a few layers to make the colors pop.
This eyeshadow is hypoallergenic and formulated with quality ingredients for people with sensitive eyes.
It’s all-day wear and is crease resistant so you don’t have to do a touch-up after a few hours.
- They blend well and wear well
- Easy to apply
- Pigments aren’t too heavy or light
- Hard to use the curved applicator
Factors to consider when choosing eyeshadow for sensitive eyes
Powder or cream eyeshadow
You must check the ingredients of products you apply on your face if you have sensitive eyes.
It can be a bit hard to find a cream-based eyeshadow, but if you do get one with a formula that doesn’t irritate your skin and the best thing about this product is that it doesn’t flake or fall at the corner of your eyes, it stays put.
Powdered eyeshadows, on the other hand, can get into your eyes and irritate them.
But if you want to use it, use an eyeshadow primer that works with sensitive eyes, or get an eyeshadow that you can apply wet or dry.
This will allow you to set it and reduce the chances of the powder getting into your eyes.
Makeup tips for sensitive eyes
Clean your brushes
Cleaning your brushes can be a boring job, but if you don’t clean them you allow bacteria to build up which will cause infections and irritations on your skin.
This is worse especially for people with sensitive eyes and skin.
The best option would be to clean your brushes at least once a week to avoid germs or bacteria accumulating on them.
Replace your makeup regularly
It’s difficult to toss out your makeup products, but makeup expires and you need to replace it regularly.
Mascara and eyeliners tend to dry out faster than eyeshadow and they also collect germs which isn’t good for sensitive eyes. Replace them every 3-6 months and after 2 years for your eyeshadow.
Ingredients to avoid
When you have super sensitive eyes that tend to get watery, you need to be careful and check the ingredients in the eye makeup you want to use.
Check if the formulas you’re using are gentle and free of irritants because most eye products tend to contain sensitizing ingredients with hidden fragrances like denatured or SD alcohol that have the potential to react with your eyes.
This powder creates the pigments you’ll find in many mainstream eyeshadows and is known to increase your body’s toxicity levels that can be harmful to your inner organs.
Look for names like pigment or aluminum metal on the ingredient label before buying your eyeshadow.
This is commonly used as a filler in eyeshadows and also ensures the eyeshadow gets on smoothly with a silky feel.
Talc has been linked with cancer on occasion and although there’s still a debate about it, this ingredient isn’t safe to use.
This is a compound that is mostly used in eyeshadows, mascara, and eyeliners and has been associated with cancer and toxicity levels in the organ system.
Avoid buying products with ingredients like carbon black, furnace black, lampblack, acetylene black, or D&C black no.2.
Eyeshadows with a metallic or green color will most likely contain heavy metals like chrome and nickel.
These metals have been linked to brain damage and respiratory problems and nickel can dry out your eyelids and cause them to be watery.
The degree of eye sensitivity in each person varies and it’s good to know that there are makeup products that are designed just for you.
Many brands cater to people with sensitive eyes and skin and finding the best eyeshadow for sensitive eyes will help you create the look you want without irritating your eyes.