Eye Makeup Remover vs. Face Makeup Remover – The Differences You Need To Know

There’s lots of debate regarding the use of eye makeup remover on your face or your face makeup remover around your eyes. I’ve created this eye makeup remover vs. face makeup remover piece to help you figure it all out!

Sometimes, one product runs out, or you’re in the middle of your travels when you realize you left your face of eye makeup remover behind. If you’re like me, you’re guilty of using what you’ve to compensate for the loss of the other. When you’re lucky, it does the job intended; but when you’re not, you suddenly realize there’s a reason the makeup removers are different.

Many would say that using your eye makeup remover for your face or your face makeup remover for your eyes is unwise. Why? The face makeup remover may be too strong for your eyes, or the eye makeup remover may not be adequate for face makeup removal. Still, some cleansing oils are created to tackle both the eyes and face, but let’s find out the differences or similarities between both products.

Differences Between Eye Makeup Remover and Face Makeup Remover

Product
Eye Makeup Remover
Face Makeup Remover
Common Base
Oil-based
Water-based
Key Benefit
Gentle on the skin around the eyes
Gentle but effective on removal of layers of makeup
Removal method
Minimal press and sweep
Press and sweep

Eye Makeup Remover vs. Face Makeup Remover – A Quick Comparison

Sensitivity

The skin around your eyes is thin, delicate, and the most sensitive over the rest of your face. Eye makeup removers are created with that in mind – they have to be gentle enough to avoid irritating the skin around the eye, but strong enough to remove eye makeup like mascara, eyeshadow, and eyeliners.

On the other hand, face makeup remover may not be the wisest choice for use on your eye area. Think of most face makeup removers as a harsher cleanser than the eye makeup removers – enough to take off layers of makeup and dirt accumulated during the day. Always read the instructions on either makeup remover to see if it is suitable for both uses.

Base Used

You may already know that both makeup removers are either water-based or oil-based. Most eye makeup removers are oil-based; mostly so they can get rid of the toughest and thickest layers of waterproof eye makeup you wear. Using such a makeup remover on your face, especially if your skin is acne-prone and sensitive may lead to irritation and breakouts.

Most face makeup removers are water-based. For example, Micellar water is a favorite water-based makeup remover that many individuals use for makeup removal on both the face and eye area. However, confirm first that it is safe to use your water-based face makeup remover on your eyes.

Necessity

Even though both makeup removers serve different purposes, you can find out if you can do without one. If you’re an eye makeup fanatic way more primping up your face, buy an eye makeup remover and use your regular cleanser for the face. Microfibre cloths can be a cheaper way to remove face makeup in such cases.

If you dabble in face makeup a lot more, you can find a face makeup remover that can remove your eye makeup as well. Just make sure to do some research to confirm the ingredients and the instructions on use for both areas.

Eye Makeup Remover Review

With the advanced technology we have, you can now find an eye makeup remover that does more than just the basic job. Spending too much time scrubbing back and forth on the delicate eye area isn’t a great idea. A good eye makeup remover takes a few sweeps, and you’re done.

La Roche Posay.jpg

La Roche-Posey Respectissime ranks high on the list of best eye makeup removers to have. Not only is it gentle on your delicate skin, but it is also effective on waterproof eye makeup. The ingredients are free from parabens, fragrances, and sulfates that are harmful on your skin.

Pros

  • Friendly on sensitive skin
  • Easy to use

Cons

  • Slightly pricey

 

View price on Amazon

 

Face Makeup Remover Review

Whether you’re feeling lazy, had a long day, or indulged in a couple of drinks, removing your makeup is one rule you cannot break. All the grime, oil, and makeup accumulated all day are a recipe for breakouts or worse. Buying the right face makeup ensures you remove all the makeup, and leave your skin breathing throughout the night.

Garnier Micellar.jpg

Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water is popular among women all over the world, and with good reason. You can remove all your makeup with this product – face makeup, lipstick, mascara, and foundation. The steps are pretty simple too: Saturate your cotton pad, press, and wipe!

Pros

  • Suitable for all skin types (sensitive included)
  • Great value for your money

Cons

  • There are fake bottles around (look for safety seal)

 

View price on Amazon

 

Conclusion

When you compare eye makeup remover vs. face makeup remover, there is no general answer on what to use. The choice will depend on your skin type and the amount and type of makeup you use. However, in this comparison, I’d recommend Garnier’s Cleansing Water for the all rounded results it gives.

FAQ Section

How can I remove eye makeup without irritating the eyes?

First, close your eyes shut and make sure none of the makeup remover gets into your eyes. After soaking your cotton pad with the remover, press gently and try to remove the makeup in one quick sweep.

Why does makeup remover burn my eyes?

If the type of eye makeup remover you use is too strong, it can irritate the eye area. Also, scrubbing too hard or getting some of the remover into your eyes can be reasons you feel the stinging or burning sensation.

Do you need to wash your face after using makeup remover?

It is advisable to wash your face and moisturize after using your makeup remover. Makeup removers can dry out your skin, and are not the same as cleansers unless otherwise indicated.

Which makeup remover is best for oily skin?

Finding makeup remover for oily skin can be tricky since some can dry your skin off too much while others leave it even oilier. Look for an oil-free makeup remover to avoid leaving an oily residue behind.

Marie Stevenson

Having been a victim of counterfeit products Marie Stevenson decided to comb various markets both online and physical to find the best original beauty products for women. The influx of counterfeits is palpitation inducing especially when you consider the aftermath. The consequences of using fake makeup or tanning lotions can be quite expensive and life-threatening and the reason why Marie decided to provide you with insightful information that will actually enhance your health. Apart from saving the world from the influx of fake beauty products Marie is a dedicated environmentalist, loves to travel and read. Her famous line is that if you believe it and have the passion to do something right then don’t let someone else discourage since they don’t understand where you are coming from.

Leave a Comment